6 former Shin Bet (Israeli FBI) heads speak out about Israeli occupation

"[Shin Bet leaders] are practical. ...They have used all the measures — in order to suppress any kind of terrorist activity. These are the guys... that have conducted targeted assassinations, tortured people in order to get intelligence ... and at the end of the day when they look at the Israeli society and they are saying in a loud and clear voice, 'Enough of the occupation. We cannot win this battle. We have to try to compromise. If we try to eat the whole cake and not share it we will lose.' And this fact surprised me completely, because you don't think this is what a security official will think." - Filmmaker and former IDF soldier Dror Moreh

http://www.npr.org/2013/02/28/172706218/the-gatekeepers-offer-candid-assessment-of-israels-security

Shin Bet is Israel's anti-terror national security agency. Their retired leaders are not leftists, but probably center-right. They are proud of and have no problem with the tough tactics they practiced in the name of protecting Israel. But use them when necessary, and as part of a larger intelligent strategy. They criticize the out-of-touch right-wing leadership that is misusing the security services and not making Israel safer in the long run.

Since the 1970's, they have had to investigate Jewish terrorists too - usually settler religious fanatics who want war to fulfill scripture (so they fight the peace process and do things to provoke the Palestinians to violence, which would justify Jewish reprisals). This culminated in the assassination of Rabin, which opened the flood gates to much more illegal settlement activity by Israel's fringe right wing (great idea to allow the most radical, uncompromising Jews to live in occupied lands among angry Palestinians, huh?). Every time there is talk of abandoning settlements and such, these extremists rise up and even burn mosques and kill Palestinians. Shin Bet found it difficult to investigate and punish them though (and many were released due to political pressure from pro-settlement leaders). They stopped a plan to bomb the Dome of the Rock (one of Islam's holiest sites) which would have incited a global religious war, only to watch the smiling perpetrators get released to cheering crowds (that did not represent the Israeli mainstream).

Former PM Sharon was the "father" of the Israeli settlement program, but as the more centrist Likud leader, he saw that they were now a liability and hurting Israel's future. He pulled Israel out of Gaza and wanted to do the same in the W Bank (as part of a larger peace deal), but suffered a stroke and his leaderless party lost. Then right wing Bibi took power and peace was off the agenda. Sharon had the credibility to broker the deal because of his former hardline rep, but actually the extreme right in Israel was the biggest roadblock. There were plots to kill Sharon (and not by Hamas), maybe even more than those against Rabin.

One of the Shin Bet leaders, Avraham Shalom, grew up in pre-WWII Austria. He was almost beaten to death by his Austrian classmates for being Jewish. Now in old age, he compared the IDF occupation of Palestine with the German occupation of Europe (not the Holocaust, but the military occupation). "We have become cruel." That means a lot coming from a Jew who experienced the worst racism and occupation.